Lisa

Hook size is definitely wrong. I had to go up to a 6.5mm to be close. The esc rows were still too tight/bunchy and going up to an 8mm was not really an option. It isn't as noticeable in the body, but the arms looked ridiculous (and the dec were on the esc rows). Frogged and did them fully in sc/dc. Colorina did not help with the tension as it would often go from DK weight to fingering (and usually during the esc rows). This pattern may have gone better (design wise) if the suggested yarn would have been a consistent thickness.
Stitch count at cuff for the different sizes is odd, ie. the 3XL will have extra tight sleeves and the M will have baggy sleeves. Also, the stitch count listed on the shoulder seaming instructions are also incorrect. Front panels are 23/25/27/31/35/39/43/45/47 but the seaming instructions list 27/29/29/33/37/41/45/45/53.
It was a very easy pattern but, between the errors and tension issues with the design, it was not the best.

Cynthia

Went up a full hook size on the esc stitches and they are still too tight/bunchy.
And the length is nowhere close to what it should be.
It’s almost like the suggested hook size is wrong - or else they crochet VERY loosely.
Have had to frog and redo multiple times to try and adjust to find larger hook sizes that work on those rows - and Colorina is very unforgiving to frog.